Home

Meetings

Presentations

Library and Resources

Reference Assistance

Data and Statistics

Colleagues

Discussion

Pathnotes

Conference

About IPCN

Search

Groupsite

 
Annotated Bibliography

Author(s):Ziskin, M., Gross, J., and Hossler, D
Title:Institutional practices and student persistence: Extending the empirical record
Source:http://pas.indiana.edu/cb/docs/ZiskinGrossHossl...
Date:2006
Organization:Indiana Project on Academic Success
Short Description:This paper explores how actionable institutional practices and structures, in combination with student behaviors, play a role in students’ institutional commitment and intent to persist at the end of the first year of college.
Annotation:This paper explores how actionable institutional practices and structures, in combination with student behaviors, play a role in students’ institutional commitment and intent to persist at the end of the first year of college. Logistic regression is used to examine the influence that student characteristics, social integration, and academic integration experiences have on college students’ intent to persist
Link: View Full Text

Print Bibliography: HyperLink 

Is this item's link broken? Report Broken Link

Associated Keywords:
Accountability and Productivity (Postsecondary)
Data
Documents
Educational Attainment/College Degree Completion
Evaluation
First Year of College
Persistence/Retention

Similar Items:
Promoting academic momentum at community colleges: Challenges and opportunities
Survey of Entering Student Engagement (SENSE)
Starting right: A first look at engaging entering students
First-year programs: A practice brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
Diplomas and dropouts: Which colleges actually graduate their students (and which don't)
Toward informative assessment and a culture of evidence: Results from strengthening pre-collegiate education in community colleges
Top gainers: Some public four-year colleges and universities make big improvements in minority graduation rates
Top gap closers: Some public four-year colleges and universities have made good progress in closing graduation rate gaps
The promise of proficiency: How college proficiency information can help high schools drive student success
Re-imagining community colleges in the twenty-first century
Lessons from Achieving the Dream for federal efforts to improve college completion rates
Gaining support from campus leaders: A project brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
Increasing student engagement through faculty development: A practice brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
A stronger nation through higher education: How and why Americans must meet a "big goal" for college attainment
Aligning multiple campus initiatives: A practice brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
Cultivating generative connections, commitment, and engagement among campus constituencies: A practice brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
Modeling Hispanic-Serving Institutions (HSIs): Campus practices that work for Latino students
Choosing to improve: Voices from colleges and universities with better graduation rates
Improving student attainment in community colleges: Institutional characteristics and policies
Strengthening institutional research and information technology capacity through Achieving the Dream: Principles and practices of student success
Promising practices: What works in the midwest: A report from the Wisconsin Center for the Advancement of Postsecondary Education (WISCAPE)
Promoting a culture of student success: How colleges and universities are improving degree completion
PERSIST (Guide to improve higher education persistence, retention, and success)
New approaches to improving college access, persistence, and success: Three exemplary postsecondary opportunity programs
Lumina Foundation focus: The productivity push: System wide reform allows Arizona to serve more students
Big gaps, small gaps: Some colleges and universities do better than others in graduating African-American students
Big gaps, small gaps: Some colleges and universities do better than others in graduating Hispanic students
Restoring the balance: Dollars, values, and the future of college sports
Effective college access, persistence and completion programs and strategies for underrepresented student populations: Opportunities for scaling up
Pathway to the baccalaureate: How one community college is helping underprepared students succeed
Basics of longitudinal cohort analysis: Principles and practices of student success
Keeping score when it counts: Graduation rates for 2010 NCAA men's division 1 basketball tournament teams
A sharper focus on technical workers: How to educate and train for the global economy
Student success: Understanding graduation and persistence rates
Descriptive summary of 1995-96 beginning postsecondary students: Six years later
Power tools: Designing state community college data and performance measurement systems to increase student success
A good start: Two-year effects of a freshman learning community program at Kingsborough Community College
Is student success labeled institutional failure? Student goals and graduation rates in the accountability debate at community colleges
Community college student success: What institutional characteristics make a difference
Do student success courses actually help community college students succeed?
Latino student success at Hispanic serving institutions
National evaluation of Upward Bound: Summary of first-year impacts and program operations
National study of student support services. Third-year longitudinal study results and program implementation study update
Descriptive summary of 2003-04 beginning postsecondary students: Three years later
Field guide for improving student success
Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS)
Emerging Hispanic Serving Institutions (HSIs): Serving Latino students
Achieving the Dream: Evidence of change
Using data to increase student success: A focus on diagnosis: Principles and practices of student success
2009 Student retention practices and strategies at four-year and two-year institutions
Best practices in statewide articulation and transfer systems
Baccalaureate success of transfers and rising four-year college juniors
Making the connections: Connecting state and institutional policies to improve student success
Making connections: Dimensions of student engagement (2009 CCSSE Findings)
Measuring student achievement at postsecondary institutions
IPEDS Data Center
Moving beyond access: College success for low-income, first generation students
Outcomes of high impact practices for underserved students: A review of the literature
National studies find TRIO programs effective at increasing college enrollment and graduation
Institutional transfer and the management of risk in higher education
Building student success from the ground up: A case study of an Achieving the Dream college
From soldier to student: Easing the transition of service members on campus
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: Academic outcomes of high risk students
Community colleges: Special supplement to the Condition of Education 2008
Characteristics and destinations of students who transfer: Second report
The learning communities demonstration: Rationale, sites, and research design
Course-taking patterns and preparation for postsecondary education in California's public university systems among minority youth
Moving into students' spaces: The impact of academic advising on student engagement among undecided students
Collecting survey data for assessment: A practice brief based on BEAMS project outcomes
Non-traditional student success in public two-year colleges
Imagine success: Engaging entering students
The road less traveled? Students who enroll in multiple institutions
Profile of undergraduates in U.S. postsecondary education institutions: 2003-04, With a special analysis of community college students
A whole 'nother world: Students navigating community college
A multi-institution analysis of the effects of campus-based financial aid on student persistence at public four-year institutions
PERSIST: A comprehensive guide for student success in higher education
Persistence and attainment of 2003-04 beginning postsecondary students: After three years
Using longitudianal data to increase community college student success: A guide to measuring milestone and momentum point achievement
Helping low-wage workers persist in education programs
Graduation rate watch: Making minority student success a priority
One step from the finish line: Higher college graduation rates are within our reach
Bridging the gap: Academic preparation and postsecondary success of first generation students
Waiting to attend college: Students who delay postsecondary enrollment
High school academic preparation and postsecondary progress
Paths to persistence: An analysis of research on program effectiveness at community colleges
Making opportunity affordable: Reinvesting in college access and success
Income and financial aid effects on persistence and degree attainment in public colleges
Postsecondary success
Academic progress/graduation success rate study of Division I NCAA women’s and men’s basketball tournament teams
Evaluating student success interventions: Principles and practices of student success
A national study of institutional policies for the evaluation of transfer applicants
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: Attendance and completion patterns
Increasing college success: A roadmap for governors
Lumina Foundation Focus: Off the charts: Columns of data provide support for student achievement
Investing in change: How much do Achieving the Dream colleges spend - and from what resources - to become data-driven institutions
Altered state: How the Virginia community college system has used Achieving the Dream to improve student success
College and university commitments to student access and success: An overview of institutional postsecondary opportunity programs
National Center for Academic Transformation
The rising price of inequality: How inadequate grant aid limits college access and persistence
Effectiveness of fully online courses for college students: Response to a department of education meta-analysis
What impacts student success in college persistence and completion?
The relationship between AP exam performance and college outcomes
Enrollment in postsecondary institutions Fall 2008; graduation rates, 2002 and 2005 cohorts; and financial statistics, 2008
Special report on the transfer admission process: National Association for College Admission Counseling
Engaging faculty in the Achieving the Dream initiative: Principles and practices of student success
Promising practices: What works in the Midwest: New approaches to improving college access, persistence, and success: Three exemplary postsecondary opportunity programs
Expanding access and opportunity: The impact of the Gates Millennium Scholars program (2010 Update)
The effects of public support on college attainment
Rising to the challenge: Hispanic college graduation rates as a national priority
Inventing Hispanic serving institutions (HSIs): The basics
Hitting home: Quality, cost, and access challenges confronting higher education today
Students entering and leaving postsecondary occupational education: 1995-2001
Act on fact: Using data to improve student success
The art of student retention
Effects of students’ middle school and high school experiences on completion of the bachelor’s degree: How can school counselors make a difference?
Raising the graduation rates of low-income college students
Mexican Americans and other Latinos in postsecondary education: Institutional influences
Part II: Institutional strategies, strategies to increase student success
Part I: Barriers to student success on college campuses
The path through graduate school: A longitudinal examination 10 years after bachelor’s degree
Committing to student engagement: Reflections on CCSSE's first five years: 2007 findings
Lumina Foundation Lessons: Students aren't just data points, but numbers do count
Building a culture of evidence for community college student success: Early progress in the Achieving the Dream initiative
Validity of high-school grades in predicting student success beyond the freshman year: High-school record vs. standardized tests as indicators of four-year college outcomes
Educational programs and projects that address the needs of low-income students
Demography is not destiny: Increasing the graduation rates of low-income college students at large public universities
Engaging students, challenging the odds
Building a strong community college system for the state of Indiana: A best practices study
The Bologna Process for US eyes: Re-learning higher education in the Age of Convergence
Enrollment in postsecondary institutions, Fall 2006; Graduation rates, 2000 and 2003 cohorts; and financial statistics, Fiscal Year 2006
The community college transfer calculator: Identifying the course-taking patterns that predict transfer to a four-year institution
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: Developmental education: Completion status and outcomes
Ready to assemble: A model state higher education accountability system
The other college: Retention and completion rates among two-year college students
Passing the torch: Strategies for innovation in community college ESL
The impact of postsecondary remediation using a regression discontinuity approach: Addressing endogenous sorting and noncompliance
A model of success: The model institution's for excellence program's successful leadership in STEM education (1995-2007)
Opportunity matters: A journal of research informing educational opportunity, practice and programs
Test drive: Six states pilot better ways to measure and compare community college performance
Community college success: Is it a pathway to opportunity?
Accelerating Latino success at Texas border institutions: Possibilities and challenges
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: Characteristics of students who stop out
Lumina Foundation Focus: No more kid stuff: Colleges and universities take a mature approach to serving adult students
More guidance, better results? Three-year effects of an enhanced student services program at two community colleges
Military service members and veterans in higher education: What the new GI Bill may mean for postsecondary institutions
Are student employment and academic success linked?
College readiness for the 21st century: A blog on college readiness in practice and policy
Sexual orientation and outcomes in college
Growing What Works Database
Paying for college success: An introduction to the performance-based scholarship demonstration
Achieving the Dream Equity Resource Center
Promoting gatekeeper course success among community college students needing remediation: Findings and recommendations from a Virginia study
Why have college completion rates declined? An analysis of changing student preparation and collegiate resources
Four steps to finishing first in higher education: A guide for state policymakers
LE,NONET pilot project: Interim evaluation report
Steps to success: Analyzing milestone achievement to improve community college student outcomes
Community college student outcomes: Limitations of the Intergrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) and recommendations for improvement
Community colleges as gateway and gatekeeper: Moving beyond the access "saga" to outcome equity
Calculating cost-return for investments in students success
Work less, study more, & succeed: How financial supports can improve postsecondary success
Charting a necessary path: The baseline report of public higher education systems in the Access to Success initiative
Higher education performance funding 2.0 - Funding degrees (tip sheet)
Investing in Indiana's adult workers: Increasing financial aid opportunities
How colleges organize themselves to increase student persistence: Four-year institutions (College Board study on student retention)
Persistence in post-secondary education in Canada: The latest research
Promoting partnerships for student success: Lessons from the SSPIRE Initiative
Postsecondary opportunity programs: Defining and improving an educational policy innovation
Postsecondary institutions and price of attendance in the United States: Fall 2008 and degrees and other awards conferred: 2007-08, and 12-month enrollment 2007-08
What we must to do to create a system that prepares students for college success
Students who study science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) in postsecondary education
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: Late stop-outs
Examining the pre-college attributes and values of Latina/o graduates
Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders: Facts, not fiction: Setting the record straight
Supporting success: Improving higher education outcomes for students from foster care—A framework for program enhancement
Learning better together: The impact of learning communities on the persistence of low-income students
Do community colleges provide a viable pathway to a Baccalaureate degree?
First-generation students: Undergraduates whose parents never enrolled in postsecondary education
The impacts of regular Upward Bound: Results from the third follow-up data collection
A study of the Talent Search program: Analysis and highlights
Best practices in recruiting and retaining minority graduate students
Rewarding persistence: Effects of a performance-based scholarship program for low-income parents
The costs of failure factories in American higher education
Community college transfer and articulation policies: Looking beneath the surface
Do increases in Pell and other grant awards increase college-going among lower income high school graduates? Evidence from a 'natural experiment'
Keeping score when it counts: Assessing the 2008-09 bowl-bound college football teams: Academic performance improves, but race still matters
Achieving the Dream Data Notes: When do students stop out?
Improving high-school-to-college transition through leadership and governance
Engaged learning: Fostering success for all students
What works for Latino students
Opening the door to the American Dream: Increasing higher education access and success for immigrants
Indiana college completion rates 2007
Answering the question that matters most: Has student achievement increased since No Child Left Behind?
Adult learning focused institution (ALFI) initiative
Status and trends in the education of racial and ethnic minorities
Beyond access: How the first semester matters for community college students' aspirations and persistence
College access in Indiana and the United States 2007: Improving college access and success for Indiana adults 25 and over
Education watch Indiana: Key education facts and figures 2006
The national articulation and transfer network
The study of economic, informational, and cultural barriers to community college student transfer access at selective institutions: National estimates of transfer access and baccalaureate degree attainment at four-year colleges and universities
A supporting role: How accreditors can help promote the success of community college students
Do support services at community colleges encourage success or reproduce disadvantage?
Promising practices for community college developmental education
Remediation in the community college: An evaluator's perspective
Enrollment status and outcomes
Engaging faculty and staff: An imperative for fostering retention, advising, and smart borrowing
The real technology challenge
Achievement and attainment in Chicago charter schools
The growing imbalance: Recent trends in U.S. postsecondary education finance
Characteristics of undergraduate borrowers: 1999-2000
Increasing success for underserved students: Redesigning introductory courses
College Results Online
College success programs
The first year experience: Are we making it any better
Findings from the Condition of Education 2001: Students whose parents did not go to college
Pathways to a four-year degree: Determinants of transfer and degree completion
Measuring up 2006
En route to the baccalaureate: Community college student outcomes
Does public funding for higher education matter?
Stepping stones to a degree: The impact of enrollment pathways and milestones on older community college student outcomes
Placing college graduation rates in context: How 4-Year college graduation rates vary with selectivity and the size of low-income enrollment
Opening doors: Promoting student success in community college and beyond
The toolbox revisited: Paths to degree completion from high school through college
Student retention and graduation: Facing the truth, living with the consequences
Early exit: Understanding adult attrition in accelerated and traditional postsecondary programs
Collegiate learning assessement project
Building pathways to success for low-skill adult students: Lessons for community college policy and practice from a longitudinal student tracking study
The effects of merit-based financial aid on course enrollment, withdrawal, and completion in college
Complete College America
Keeping score when it counts: Assessing the 2009-10 bowl-bound college football teams - academic performance improves but race still matters
The Equity Scorecard: A collaborative approach to assess and respond to racial and ethnic disparities in student outcomes
Bridging the gaps to success: Promising practices for promoting transfer among low-income and first generation students: An in-depth study of six exemplary community colleges in Texas
Good data. Better policy. Stronger commitment. Improved outcomes.
First-generation students: Undergraduates whose parents never enrolled in college
Open-access colleges responsible for greatest gains in graduation rates
Scaling up learning communities: The experience of six community colleges
Reaching higher: Strategic initiatives for higher education in Indiana (Updated 2010 Version)
Dollars and sense: How "career first" programs like Year Up benefit youth and employers
Advancing by degrees: A framework for increasing college completion
Minorities and the recession era college enrollment boom
Rebalancing the mission: The community college completion challenge
The college completion agenda: State policy guide
From access to success: A funder's guide to ensuring more Americans earn postsecondary degrees
Complete to compete: Common college completion metrics
Learning communities for students in developmental reading: An impact study at Hillsborough Community College
Southern Regional Education Board annual report: The essentials: What really counts in improving education
Beyond the rhetoric: Improving college readiness through coherent state policy
Grantmakers for Education
Postsecondary educational trajectories of urban youth: Addressing vulnerabilities and barriers to enrollment and persistence
Bridging the gaps to success: Promising practices for promoting transfer among low-income and first-generation students: An in-depth study of six exemplary community colleges in Texas
Federal higher education policy priorities and the Asian American and Pacific Islander community
ETS Policy Notes: Advancing learning for our diverse adult population
Turning community college drop-outs into graduates
A portrait of low-income young adults in education
The course of innovation: Using technology to transform higher education
Postsecondary education and training as we know it is not enough: Why we need to leaven postsecondary strategy with more attention to employment policy, social policy, and career and technical education in high school
Employment experience of youths: Results from a longitudinal survey
Florida policy options to accelerate Latino student success in higher education
Recommendations for incorporating postsecondary and workforce data into statewide longitudinal data systems
Improving education and employment for disadvantaged young men: Proven and promising strategies
The quality imperative: Match ambitious goals for college attainment with an ambitious vision for learning
Financial incentives for institutions and individuals: Survey findings from the Midwest and the Nation
American community colleges and the academic crisis of basic skills: Adult student success
Global Skills for Global Completion
Expanding access and opportunity: The Washington State Achievers Program
Addressing the American male imperative in higher education: Implications for public and research universities
Fueling the race to postsecondary success: A 48-institution study of prior learning assessment and adult student outcomes
Terms of engagement: Men of color discuss their experiences in community college
Leisure college USA: The decline in student study time
Opening doors: Support success: Services that may help low-income students succeed in community college
Strategies for improving student success in postsecondary education
Just for the kids
California Community Colleges: Making them stronger and more affordable
One day I will make it: A study of adult student persistence in library literacy programs
Who's left behind? Immigrant children in high and low LEP schools
The postsecondary educational experiences of high school career and technical education concentrators: Selected results from the NELS: 88/2000 Postsecondary education transcript study
NCAA Federal Graduation Rates Data Archive
Intercollegiate athletes and effective educational practice: Winning combination or losing effort
A test of leadership: Charting the future of U.S. higher education
Education and the economy: An indicators report
College rankings reformed: The case for a new order in higher education
OECD Programme for international student assessment
From high school to the future: A first look at Chicago public school graduates' college enrollment, college preparation, and graduation from four-year colleges
Increasing rates of school completion: Moving from policy and research to practice
Paying for persistence: Early results of a Louisiana scholarship program for low-income parents attending community college
The role of academic and non-academic factors in improving college retention
First generation college students: A literature review
Data sources for improving college access and success
Lumina Foundation focus: Refuse to lose: Today’s colleges and universities must work to foster student success
A matter of degrees: Improving graduation rates in four-year colleges and universities
How curriculum influences college persistence in Indiana and the nation
College persistence on the rise? Changes in 5-year degree completion and postsecondary persistence rates between 1994 and 2000
A step toward college success: Assessing attainment among Indiana's Twenty-first Century Scholars
Addressing the shame of higher education: Programs that support college enrollment and retention of African-American males
Postsecondary institutions in the United States: Fall 2004 and degrees and other awards conferred: 2003-04
Access and persistence: Winter 2006
ACSFA policy brief: The toolbox and student aid policy
Diversity and persistence in Indiana higher education: The impact of preparation, major choices, and financial aid
Institutional graduation rate for 1985 entering cohorts
Institutional grants and baccalaureate degree attainment
Enrollment in Postsecondary Institutions, Fall 2004; Graduation Rates; 1998 and 2001 Cohorts; and Financial Statistics; Fiscal Year 2004
Measuring up 2006 state report card on education: Indiana
Recent changes in the entry of Hispanic and White youth into college
Good policy, good practice: Improving outcomes and productivity in higher education, a guide for policymakers
Reaching higher college completion (working paper)
Reaching higher with accountability (working paper)
Crafting a new vision for high school: How states can join academic and technical studies to promote more powerful learning
What works in remediation: Lessons from 30 years of research
Minority males: Race/ethnicity, gender, and student outcomes
Enhancing student services at Lorain County Community College: Early results from the Opening the Doors demonstration in Ohio
The CollegeKeys Compact: Getting ready, getting in, and getting through college: Expanding options for low-income students
MHEC in Indiana: 2006-07
Statement of principals: Twenty-first century skills and the reauthorization of NCLB/ESEA
Education longitudinal study of 2002 (ELS:2002): A first look at the initial postsecondary experiences of the high school Sophomore class of 2002
The postsecondary achievement of participants in dual enrollment: An analysis of student outcomes in two states
Beyond myths: The growth and diversity of Asian American college freshmen: 1971-2005
Student success in college: Puzzle, pipeline, or pathway?
Camino de la universidad: The road to college
Unmasking the effects of student engagement on college grades and persistence
No Child Left Behind: State report card 2005-2006
Education watch Alabama: Key education facts and figures 2004
Education watch Florida: Key education facts and figures 2004
Education watch Florida: Key education facts and figures 2006
What community college management practices are effective in promoting student success? A study of high- and low-impact institutions
First in my family: A profile of first-generation college students at four-year institutions since 1971 - executive summary
Relationships between students' high school and middle school experiences and later completion of a Bachelor's degree
California policy options to accelerate Latino success in higher education
Graduate migration from Indiana's postsecondary institutions
Adult learners in higher education: Barriers to success and strategies to improve results
Returning to learning: Adults' success in college is key to America's future
Keeping America's promise: A report on the future of the community college
Degree completions in areas of national need: 1996-97 to 2001-02
Addressing America's dropout challenge: State efforts to boost graduation rates require federal support
The impact of diversity on college students: The latest research
U.S. student and adult performance on international assessments of educational achievement
Nontraditional undergraduates
Transforming America's community colleges: A federal policy proposal to expand opportunity and promote economic prosperity
Keeping score when it counts: Graduation rates and academic progress rates (APR) for 2009 NCAA men's division I basketball tournament teams
The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport (TIDES)
Keeping score when it counts: Sweet 16 men's and women's teams: A look at their academic success
Keeping score when it counts: Graduation rates and academic progress rates (APR) for 2009 NCAA women's and men's division I basketball tournament teams
When Johnny (or Janelle) comes marching home: National, state, and institutional efforts in support of veterans' education
OEDb's Online College Rankings 2009
College-ready students, student-ready colleges: An agenda for improving degree completion in postsecondary education
Barriers to college attainment: Lessons from Chicago
Ready to succeed: Changing systems to give California's foster children the opportunities they deserve to be ready for and succeed in school
Referral, enrollment, and completion in developmental education sequences in community colleges
Second to none in attainment, discovery, and innovation: The national agenda for higher education
Strategic directions in Indiana education
A profile of the Ronald McNair postbaccalaureate achievement program: 1999-2000
A profile of the Talent Search program: 1998-99
Upward Bound Math-Science: Program description and interim impact estimates
Helping community college students cope with financial emergencies: Lessons from the Dreamkeepers and Angel Fund financial aid programs
Promoting student success in community colleges by increasing student support services
Career academies: Long-term impacts on labor market outcomes, educational attainment, and transitions to adulthood
College access and success state data
Foundations for success: Short-term impacts report
Setting up success in developmental education: How state policy can help community colleges improve student success outcomes
A new goal for America's high schools: College preparation for all
Dynamic annotated bibliographies from the IPCN online college access library
National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment
How much are college students borrowing?
Serving those who serve: Higher education and America's veterans
Benchmarks: WICHE Region 2009
Parental transfers, student achievement, and the labor supply of college students
Getting started at community colleges: Reducing unplanned pregnancy and strengthening academic achievement
ACE Online Information Center
Achieving success: The state policy newsletter of Achieving the Dream: Community Colleges Count: Winter 2010
Accountability for equitable outcomes in higher education
Strong students, strong workers: Models for student success through workforce development and community college partnerships
With their whole lives ahead of them: Myths and realities about why so many students fail to finish college
Taking stock: Higher education and Latinos
Interventions to support readiness, recruitment, access, transition, and retention for postsecondary education success: An equity of opportunity policy and practice analysis
Working too hard to make the grade: How fewer work hours and more financial aid can help California community college students succeed
The high cost of low educational performance: The long-run economic impact of improving PISA outcomes